Foodie by April

Local restaurant reviews by an food explorer & enthusiast!

South Edison, Montauk, NY

Leave a comment

We headed out to Montauk for two nights at the beginning of July, and it was hard to choose where we were going to eat dinner. I’m glad we took a chance and tried South Edison. Reservations are a MUST during the high season in Montauk, and usually I’d make sure to have ours set up about one week in advance. But this time I waited until we checked into our hotel and called South Edison and they weren’t super busy for a Monday night. The key is that this wasn’t the weekend, or we wouldn’t have stood a chance of getting in.  When we arrived, the place was buzzing and quickly starting to fill up. It’s only because we arrived at about 6:30 that we didn’t have to wait for our table. Soon enough, the place was packed!

In all of my adventures in eating so far, I hadn’t tried grilled baby octopus. We had the baby octopus tacos. It took me by surprise that the baby octopus was extremely flavorful from some Mexican cheese and a bit of Serrano pepper (not too hot for me and I am a baby when it comes to heat) , and not at all chewy! The octopus was cooked perfectly. The presentation at South Edison was beautiful – each dish was crafted by an artist who took great care with how the dish was plated. I stepped outside of my comfort zone even further, and had something else I never had before – porgy. This was one of their seasonal specials, and it was not fishy at all.  I don’t know about you, but I can’t eat salmon anymore.  I used to like it, but one day I found it to taste very fishy, and that did it for me. I just can’t eat it without it tasting extremely fishy. That being said, my first question to the server was to determine if porgy tastes anything like salmon, which I can’t stand. As I write this, it’s hard to remember what type of sauce gently covered the porgy since it was over two months ago when we were there, but I know it was very flavorful without being overbearing.  The portions aren’t huge at South Edison, but that’s okay with me – I don’t like leaving dinner feeling overly stuffed. I did taste the Black & Blue local sea scallops dish that my boyfriend had, and the large scallops were super sweet and I loved the flavor from being charred from the grill. I was almost sorry I didn’t order the scallops, but I love scallops and wanted to try something different.  He thought the portions were on the small side though. I was happy with the size of my meal, as I had room for dessert at the bakery in Montauk.  (Don’t miss out on trying the jelly filled croissants at the Montauk Bakery!)

Montauk is pretty crazy during the summer or high season (July and August), but it’s also the place to be to check out great local seafood.  I’ve been in Montauk in November also and it has a quiet charm during winter that’s worth exploring as well. Their website is

Hope you have an exciting food experience yourself soon 🙂

This gallery contains 3 photos

Javier’s Café, Smithtown, NY

Leave a comment

There’s a new breakfast/lunch place in town and it competes with one of the other heavy hitters for breakfast and lunch (Maureen’s Kitchen) – it’s called Javier’s Cafe on Main Street in Smithtown.  They don’t have a website yet, as they just opened their doors about a month ago (in mid-June)…but here’s some info I found when I googled them: (Newsday’s brief announcement about their opening).  Or, here’s more detailed info from the Smithtown Patch:

It’s hard to write this and not compare Javier’s to Maureen’s Kitchen, since the chef and owner, Javier, worked as the chef for Maureen’s for 16 years.  If you’ve been to Maureen’s before, and came to Javier’s then you’d definitely have the feeling that this was a smaller version of Maureen’s – every bit as tasty and the service was great!  We went there at the end of June, and since we were only two people, we got seated right away.  The steady stream of customers kept flowing in.  The servers were very attentive and seemed that they really cared and wanted you to be genuinely happy with your meal and dining experience.  I had the Spanish Omelet and they happily made it semi-healthy for me (half egg whites and half whole eggs) – it was great and had this thick and chunky authentic Spanish salsa piled on top and they gave me some to taste prior to my meal on the side.  Like I said, they really cared that I would enjoy my meal. My boyfriend got Stuffed Peach Pecan French Toast made with fresh Challah bread – he loved it…and this is coming from someone who always gets this at Maureen’s Kitchen (sorry Maureen’s you’re still great).

I recommended this place to my coworker, and she’s already been there twice.  I’ve yet to get back there myself, but she said that her and her other half got there on a Sunday around 12:30 and could see it was getting crowded.  I’m really hoping they do well.  So far I’m very impressed with both the food and service and the decor is clean and fun – they had a very large spoon on the wall I liked 🙂  Plan on going back there soon.  Oh, and here’s another link to a local paper with info on Javier’s Cafe and other local spots as well: (scroll down for the review/info).


This gallery contains 2 photos

Hotoke Japanese Steakhouse, Smithtown, NY

Leave a comment

Hotoke is a local Japanese Hibachi restaurant that I once thought was pretty decent, but I hadn’t been there in almost a year and a half. They kept sending us coupons periodically and I had one that was expiring by June 30th- so we went on the 30th. Their service and food was not impressive and we will not be back. My boyfriend said he was “underwhelmed” to say the least. Visit their site at

We started with two appetizers:  crab cake and vegetable tempura.  The crab cake was imitation crab!  There — I said it.  As soon as I tasted it, I knew it was fake crab meat.  The imitation style has that red color.  I’ve had better crab cakes frozen from COSTCO that are from Maryland.  The veggie tempura was good – it’s hard to screw that up.  They brought out our entrées right after the servers brought us the two appetizers – within a couple of minutes of us starting to eat the appetizers we were being rushed into our dinners!  And the place wasn’t busy; they weren’t even half full.  I even had to tell them flat-out they were rushing us – not impressed at all (:

Not sure I remember what I ate there when we were there last, but I’m thinking it was hibachi shrimp.  Had the shrimp Teriyaki there and it was super bland.  My boyfriend had the Sushi Dinner from the Sushi Bar entrée section of the dinner menu.  As I said from the start, he was comparing the sushi at Hotoke with another place that we went to six months ago that he loved, and Hotoke left him feeling very underwhelmed.

Like most Japanese restaurants of late, Hotoke likes to seem “trendy”.  I guess this means that they must play loud club music while eating your meal. We thought we were getting a break from this, but at some point during our recent visit they started blasting the dance music.  Don’t know about you, but I like more traditional Asian music during my dinner experience, or more soothing low-key music.  Loud club music doesn’t help me enjoy the meal, it gives me indigestion 🙂

We were glad to have not paid full price for our dinner.  That was the last time I would get sucked into going there with the lure of the coupon they send. Next time, the coupon goes right in the garbage, and we’ll head somewhere else.

This gallery contains 4 photos

Crazy Crepe Cafe, Smithtown, NY

Leave a comment

Checked out a new small cafe in town called the Crazy Crepe Cafe. They have another location in Suffolk County, in Selden. So it’s good to see they’re doing well enough to open a second location.

Had a delicious vegetarian savory crepe- created my own crepe with spinach, feta cheese and roasted veggies. My boyfriend had a dessert crepe called the Elvis- granola, honey, peanut butter and sliced banana. He loved it!  I was impressed with my savory crepe- it was huge and I was so stuffed. And his sweet crepe was yummy.

It’s a casual, and stylish little place that’s definitely worth checking out. Website is

Cafe Baci, Westbury, NY

Leave a comment

We met our friends at Cafe Baci a couple of weeks ago on a Saturday night for dinner.  They don’t take reservations; so you have to get there no later than 5 pm to get a decent parking space and so you don’t have to wait at least 30 to 60 minutes for a table.  We got there at about 4:45 and walked in at 4:50 – parking was a breeze and there was no waiting at all.  We were seated immediately.  I’ve been there a few times for our work holiday lunch, and so I know the food is very good. Plus the portions are generous and the prices are reasonable.  It’s a decent sized space; plenty of tables, but if you get there even after 5:30, forget it, you’ll have to wait.  The food is that good.

Since my girlfriend is a regular at Baci, they brought us over an appetizer on the house right away.  It’s good to have friends with connections.  I went meatless that night since I’m trying to watch my fat intake more and didn’t get a dish loaded with cheese; my dish was called Fusilli Ortolana.  Maybe this entrée is new and the menu on their website hasn’t been updated, as this dish wasn’t listed on the menu online.  At either rate, I ended up feeling like I missed out in my attempts to “be good”.  Next time maybe I’d get the cheesy dish or at least a chicken or shrimp entrée.  On the other hand, my girlfriend got a breaded chicken dish called Fusilli Formale that she felt was a little heavy – I ended up having a few bites to make my dinner more interesting 🙂

On the whole, the food is very good and the service was great.  It’s a hopping place to be on the weekend, and I’d recommend this restaurant as a fun environment to meet good friends for a decent meal at reasonable prices.  Check out their site at

Kabul Restaurant, Huntington, NY

Leave a comment

Met my girlfriend at Kabul restaurant in Huntington a couple of days ago; it’s closer to Huntington Station, not in Huntington Village.  You can find their menu on their site:  I’ve had Afghani food only once before at a place in Huntington village a few years ago and wasn’t impressed at all, and wasn’t sure at the time if this was because my boyfriend and I chose to go vegetarian that night.  I’ve heard that food from Afghanistan is pretty heavily into meat.  I found this site from Scholastic that made me feel nostalgic for the booklets from when I was a kid:  This gives some basic facts about countries in this area of the world.  I don’t know about you, but I’m pretty geographically challenged.  I know this is because I haven’t traveled enough, and tuned out much of geography/history from when I had to learn it in school.  Thank god for my great memorization skills, or I probably would have failed these subjects.

The verdict for this place is that I wouldn’t go there again (: I wouldn’t say it was horrible food; it was just barely okay.  That’s it.  After splitting the bill, my half (with tip) was $33.00.  Not nearly worth that kind of $ for sure.  My friend and I have a wide and eclectic palate; we both love Indian and Thai food.  I thought I’d like this food, but it was pretty blah!  We got two versions of the appetizer that my friend chose – one with the meat sauce and one prepared vegetarian for me.  My friend was not impressed at all with the meat sauce and said it reminded her of “Dinty Moore” (from the can).  She said it wasn’t seasoned enough.  I had a limp dumpling type of thing (same as hers sans meat), and put some yogurt sauce on top and their jalapeno side sauce, but there was no chance of rescuing this sad dish.  The humus was uneventful. I like some of the hummus from Trader Joe’s much better. I had a shrimp dish for my entrée called Shrimp Gulpi.  My friend tasted it and commented that it seemed to have some nondescript tomato sauce.  This dish was loaded with cauliflower, and that was probably the best part of it.  It was sad and not impressive. My girlfriend is Jamaican and grew up eating goat as part of her culture.  So picking a lamb entrée to her was the closest thing to eating goat.  Let me say first that her dish was covered with a ton of their brown rice, and I was given that huge plate of the same brown rice for my dish alone 🙂 Her lamb was well hidden under the mound of brown rice; this was pretty bland and heavy rice.  Nowhere near as good as even some frozen brown rice that I use to make stir-fry dinners at home – this was bad.  Again, her meat was under-seasoned, and she didn’t like that the  plate was loaded with shredded carrots and bloated raisins either. I didn’t take my leftover rice home, but did take the shrimp, which wasn’t great on my stomach the next day.  Eating fish leftover is a bit risky.  I’ll stick to Indian next time.  My friend didn’t take a doggie bag for any of her food.  Not worth my $33.00 at all.  

Oh well…you never know until you try.  That’s why I encourage  you to try things out for yourself and decide whether or not you like Afghani food.

Buona Sera Ristorante Pizza, Smithtown, NY

Leave a comment

Tortellini al Pesto

Tortellini al Pesto

Cavatelli Roselle

Cavatelli Roselle

Sometimes it’s nice to be able to enjoy a decent meal out and not break the bank 🙂  We felt like having Italian food this past Tuesday night, and since we like to keep it local (especially on a week night), Buona Sera is a great option for really good food that you can enjoy on a budget.  Both Monday and Tuesday nights are pasta night and they give you a lot of food at a price that’s very reasonable.  Check out their site at and click on the “Offers” tab for the pasta night menu.

The place isn’t a huge space, but not super tiny either; they have booths in the restaurant portion of the place and more casual small tables in the front for pizza.  It’s comfortable – just spacious enough without feeling cramped. Service is very good and friendly.  I had the Tortellini al Pesto entrée, and it was very good, but it was loaded with some serious cream sauce with a hint of pesto. I don’t think of this as a traditional pesto sauce – more of a variation on it.  Don’t get me wrong, it was tasty, but I think they assume most people want everything loaded up with cream and in this case less would have been more.  My boyfriend had the Cavatelli Roselle, which was also in a cream sauce, but not nearly as creamy as my dish.  His was loaded up with asparagus, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach and mushrooms.  I liked it, but my dish was far more decadent than his.

Our dinner came with dessert, and I wished I had just taken it in a doggy bag since I was so stuffed from my super-heavy tortellini dish. Instead, I ate about half of the chocolate cake.  It was good, but I really wanted their cheesecake, but after my dinner I thought I’d skip that.  The zeppolis that my boyfriend ordered were delicious!  Made me nostalgic for the Italian feast I went to when I was a kid about 30 years ago.

This is a good, reliable restaurant for decent food that you can enjoy and still have money left in your wallet.  Until next time….happy spring.